All Episodes
Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.
14
Jan 2021
Episode: 257
Monster Machine
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the revenge of Miriam Rodríguez and the Happy Face Killer.7
Jan 2021
Episode: 256
Live at the Fillmore in Detroit, MI (2017)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the death of Robin Boes and murderer Lowell Amos.31
Dec 2020
Episode: 255
Live at the Chevalier Theater in Medford, MA - Late Show (2018)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover Lizzie Borden and Eastern Air Lines Shuttle Flight 1320.24
Dec 2020
Episode: 254
Little Bandit & Pirate George
On this week's quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Lori Ann Auker and The Donner Party.17
Dec 2020
Episode: 253
Live at the Arvest Bank Theatre in Kansas City (2017)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Death of Bethany Deaton and Ray & Faye Copeland.10
Dec 2020
Episode: 252
The Great La-Z-Boy Uprising: Advice Q&A
This week, Karen and Georgia lend their amateur advice to your low-stakes problems.3
Dec 2020
Episode: 251
One Vince Away
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the ‘Starlight Tours’ aka the ‘Saskatoon Freezing Deaths.’26
Nov 2020
Episode: 250
Look Who’s Crossing
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Sherri Rasmussen.19
Nov 2020
Episode: 249
Clear of Debris
In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Lavinia Fisher and murderer Byron David Smith.12
Nov 2020
Episode: 248
Congratulations, Smarty
In this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Kara Robinson Chamberlain and the University of Alabama Huntsville shooting.5
Nov 2020
Episode: 247
Champions In Our Own Ways
In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Mary Vincent and the case of Typhoid Mary.29
Oct 2020
Episode: 246
thanks for the lolz
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing and The California Witch Killers.22
Oct 2020
Episode: 245
Time Is Becoming A Serious Problem
Karen and Georgia cover the Pied Piper of Tucson.15
Oct 2020
Episode: 244
Be Nostalgic For Old Problems
Karen and Georgia cover the Claremont Serial Killer.8
Oct 2020
Episode: 243
New Escape Room
Karen and Georgia cover the I-5 Killer and the murder of Carol Thompson.1
Oct 2020
Episode: 242
Spoilerama
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Adam Walsh and the aftermath of the case.24
Sep 2020
Episode: 241
A Deep Pause
Karen and Georgia cover the Élan School and the Martha Moxley murder.17
Sep 2020
Episode: 240
Flapper Bob
In this quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover Coney Island deaths and serial killer Andrew Cunanan.10
Sep 2020
Episode: 239
Expert Conversation: David Rudolf & Sonya Pfeiffer
Karen and Georgia chat with defense attorneys David Rudolf and Sonya Pfeiffer about The Staircase documentary and their new podcast, Abuse of Power.3
Sep 2020
Episode: 238
Lady Suit
Karen and Georgia cover the Ayahuasca murders and the Beast of Gévaudan.27
Aug 2020
Episode: 237
Anti-Hype Man
Karen and Georgia cover the wickedest woman in America, Patty Cannon, and the unsolved murder of civil rights pioneer Alberta Jones.20
Aug 2020
Episode: 236
Like A Quilt
Karen and Georgia cover the Old Exchange and Provost Dungeon, and Stull Cemetery.13
Aug 2020
Episode: 235
Mr. Zip
Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Robert Spangler and the unsolved Delphi murders.6
Aug 2020
Episode: 234
Diane Steele: The Q&A
Karen and Georgia answer your summertime questions in quarantine.30
Jul 2020
Episode: 233
Free Range Children
Karen and Georgia cover the Zoot Suit Riots and the 1976 Chowchilla bus kidnapping.23
Jul 2020
Episode: 232
Live at De Meervaart in Amsterdam (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover Willem van Eijk and Elsje Christiaens.16
Jul 2020
Episode: 231
Small Bigfoot
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Michael Jordan’s father, James R. Jordan Sr.9
Jul 2020
Episode: 230
The Tide Pools of Your Life
Karen and Georgia cover the Grim Sleeper.2
Jul 2020
Episode: 229
Live at the Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall in Portland (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Larry Peyton and Beverly Allan, and Edmund Creffield and the Brides of Christ Church aka the Holy Rollers.25
Jun 2020
Episode: 228
The Season Of The Abyss
Karen and Georgia cover the St. Francis Dam Disaster and the kidnapping of Elizabeth Shoaf.18
Jun 2020
Episode: 227
Live at the Belk Theater in Charlotte (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Marcus Shrader and Blanche Taylor Moore.11
Jun 2020
Episode: 226
50 Hour Days
Karen and Georgia cover the Hart Family murder/suicide and the murder of Stephen Lawrence.4
Jun 2020
Episode: 225
It’s Jenga
Karen and Georgia cover the life of Ida B. Wells and the Stonewall Uprising.28
May 2020
Episode: 224
What’s In Your Pants?
Karen and Georgia cover the Angel Makers of Nagyrév and killer priest, Hans Schmidt.21
May 2020
Episode: 223
Live at the Paramount Theatre in Oakland (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover Zodiac Killer suspects and the murder of Stephanie Bryan.14
May 2020
Episode: 222
That’s How Water Works
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Madalyn Murray O'Hair and the survival story of Juliane Koepcke.7
May 2020
Episode: 221
Symbolic Violins
Karen and Georgia cover the rescue of Baby Jessica and the deaths of Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen.30
Apr 2020
Episode: 220
Live at the Chevalier Theatre in Medford, MA (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Mary-Lou Arruda and The Great Boston Fire of 1872.23
Apr 2020
Episode: 219
Small Pillow To Scream In
Karen and Georgia cover PSA Flight 1771 and the Kent State massacre.16
Apr 2020
Episode: 218
Good Shabbos
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Yara Gambirasio, and the crimes of Herb Coddington.9
Apr 2020
Episode: 217
Live at the Cobb Energy Performing Arts Centre in Atlanta (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the curse of Lake Lanier and Anjette Donovan Lyles.2
Apr 2020
Episode: 216
Robe Convention
Karen and Georgia cover the deaths of Grace Kelly and Kendrick Johnson.26
Mar 2020
Episode: 215
Three Small Hot Dogs
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Natalie Wood and the Boxcar Killer.19
Mar 2020
Episode: 214
Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Cecelia Bowers and the Alcatraz Escape of 1962.12
Mar 2020
Episode: 213
Live at the Northrop Auditorium in Minneapolis (2019)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Louis Arbogast and Harry Hayward.5
Mar 2020
Episode: 212
Hot Money
Karen and Georgia cover astronaut Sally Ride, the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster, and the Corpsewood Manor murders.27
Feb 2020
Episode: 211
It Was My Birthday, Forensic Files!
Karen and Georgia cover the hijacking of Pan Am Flight 73 and the Tulsa race massacre.20
Feb 2020
Episode: 210
Every Plan Is A Bad Plan
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Mary Phagan and revenge murder of Leo Frank, and the Wonderland murders.13
Feb 2020
Episode: 209
Big Sweater Energy
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Davina Buff Jones and Tiffany Taylor’s survivor story.6
Feb 2020
Episode: 208
208 - Live at the Orpheum Theater in Omaha (2019)
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of John Sheedy and Cari Farver.30
Jan 2020
Episode: 207
Not Enough Ednas
Karen and Georgia cover the Fairbanks Four and the Dixmoor Five cases and the Pillowcase Rapist.23
Jan 2020
Episode: 206
Spatula City
Karen and Georgia cover Laurie Dann, the Winnetka School shooter and Leopold and Loeb.16
Jan 2020
Episode: 205
Everyone Gets A Horse!
Karen and Georgia cover the Blackout Murders and Scott Scurlock, the Hollywood Bandit.9
Jan 2020
Episode: 204
Periodical Time Tables
Karen and Georgia cover The Butcher Baker Robert Hansen and the mysterious murder of Dorothy Jane Scott.2
Jan 2020
Episode: 203
Live at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the kidnapping of Barbara Mackle and the Barbie Bandits. With special guest Chuck Bryant.26
Dec 2019
Episode: 202
Live at the Sony Centre in Toronto (Night Two)
Karen and Georgia cover the Ant Hill Cult and the murder of Renee Sweeney.19
Dec 2019
Episode: 201
Live at Revolution Hall in Portland (2017)
Karen and Georgia cover William Scott Smith and the murders at Crater Lake.12
Dec 2019
Episode: 200
The Humility of Knowing: A 200th Episode Spectacular
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of Johnny Gosch and the Malahide massacre.5
Dec 2019
Episode: 199
Live at the Eventim Apollo in London
Karen and Georgia cover Dr. Thomas Neill Cream and the Enfield Poltergeist.28
Nov 2019
Episode: 198
Live at the Bord Gáis Energy Theatre in Dublin
Karen and Georgia cover Dorcas ‘Darkey’ Kelly and ‘Lying Eyes’ Sharon Collins.21
Nov 2019
Episode: 197
Grandma Surprise
Karen and Georgia cover the origin of ‘Stockholm Syndrome’ and Mack Ray Edwards.14
Nov 2019
Episode: 196
The Baddest Of Them All
Karen and Georgia cover the Gray Widow Murderers and the Burger Chef Murders.7
Nov 2019
Episode: 195
Live at My Favorite Weekend in Santa Barbara
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of the Salomon Family and the Thor Nis Christiansen at the Arlington Theatre. With special guest Carol Daly.31
Oct 2019
Episode: 194
The SpoOoky Halloween Hometown Special
Karen and Georgia celebrate Halloween by reading your spooky stories.24
Oct 2019
Episode: 193
The Lowest Limit
Karen and Georgia cover Gerald and Charlene Gallego, and ‘hitman’ Gary Krueger.17
Oct 2019
Episode: 192
Sticking Together & Helping Out
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of Emanuela Orlandi, and story of the Oversteegen Sisters and Hannie Schaft.10
Oct 2019
Episode: 191
Live at the Arvest Bank Theatre in Kansas City
Karen and Georgia cover the Meeks Family Murder and the Hotel President haunting.3
Oct 2019
Episode: 190
Lick The Clock
Karen and Georgia cover the Radium Girls and the murder of Lisa Cihaski.26
Sep 2019
Episode: 189
What Wonderful Luck!
Karen and Georgia cover the alleged real life story of The Orphan and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire.19
Sep 2019
Episode: 188
The You & Me Of This Group
Karen and Georgia cover the Dyatlov Pass mystery and Linda Hazzard.18
Sep 2019
Episode: Bonus
Fox’s Prodigal Son Special!
In a special presentation for Fox’s new drama Prodigal Son, Karen and Georgia cover the cases of Sante Kimes and Dolly Oesterreich. Plus, an interview with star Bellamy Young!12
Sep 2019
Episode: 187
Live at the Toyota Music Factory in Irving (Texas)
Karen and Georgia cover the Texas Cheerleader Mom Murder Plot and the case of Vicky Lyons. With special guest Skip Hollandsworth.4
Sep 2019
Episode: 186
Sprankers!
Karen and Georgia cover the obsessive case of Carl Tanzler and stories of people buried alive.29
Aug 2019
Episode: 185
400 Peeled Potatoes
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Angie Dodge and the case of Dr. Malachi Love-Robinson.22
Aug 2019
Episode: 184
Weighted Blanket
Karen and Georgia cover The Doodler and the deaths of Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon.15
Aug 2019
Episode: 183
Here We Back Are
Karen and Georgia cover Jacob Wetterling and the Mothman legend & Silver Bridge collapse.8
Aug 2019
Episode: #1
MFM The Top 3: #1 - Episode 18 - Investigateighteen Discovery
Drumroll please...It’s #1 of your top three favorite episodes: Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Mary Vincent and Franklin Delano Floyd. Original airdate: 05/27/20161
Aug 2019
Episode: #2
MFM The Top 3: #2 - Episode 129 - Coincidence Island
It’s #2 of your top three favorite episodes: Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair. Original airdate: 07/12/201825
Jul 2019
Episode: #3
MFM The Top 3: #3 - Episode 105 - Proclensity
You voted for your favorite episodes and this week it's #3: Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Christa Worthington and the case of Typhoid Mary. Original airdate: 01/25/201818
Jul 2019
Episode: 182
Something Kevin-y (The Book Q&A)
You asked, they answered! Karen and Georgia respond to all your questions about their new book, Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered.11
Jul 2019
Episode: 181
Live at the Riverside Theater in Milwaukee (2017)
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers David Spanbauer and Ed Gein.4
Jul 2019
Episode: 180
Live at the Tampa Theatre in Tampa
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Oscar Ray Bolin and Bobby Joe Long.27
Jun 2019
Episode: 179
Live at Clusterfest in San Francisco
Karen and Georgia cover the Mitchell Brothers murder and Ted Kaczynski. With special guest Patton Oswalt.20
Jun 2019
Episode: 178
Live at the Folketeatret in Oslo
Karen and Georgia cover the Isdal Woman and the Black Metal murders.13
Jun 2019
Episode: 177
Live at the Riverside Theater in Milwaukee
Karen and Georgia cover Laurie "Bambi" Bembenek and the murder of Barbara Kendhammer.6
Jun 2019
Episode: 176
The LA Book Tour Event at the Wilshire Ebell Theatre
This week, comedian Lizzy Cooperman hosts the last night of the Stay Sexy & Don't Get Murdered book tour.30
May 2019
Episode: 175
Live at the Civic Center Music Hall in Oklahoma City
Karen and Georgia cover the High Hat Club Killer and the Oklahoma City Butcher.23
May 2019
Episode: 174
Rough Winds & High Waters
Karen and Georgia cover the bodies of Mount Everest and then Karen did the Weepy-Voiced Killer.16
May 2019
Episode: 173
Live at W. L. Lyons Brown Theatre in Louisville
Karen and Georgia cover the Torture House of 1924 and the Murder of Marlene Oakes.9
May 2019
Episode: 172
I’m Fine, Look Away
Karen and Georgia cover the death of Joan Robinson Hill and the murder at Devil’s Teeth.2
May 2019
Episode: 171
Live at the Bellco Theatre in Denver
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Adolph Coors III and the Colorado Cannibal.25
Apr 2019
Episode: 170
Habeas Delicious
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Helle Crafts and the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse.18
Apr 2019
Episode: 169
This Old Sandwich
Karen and Georgia cover the Power Rangers Murder(s) and the murder of Denise Huber.11
Apr 2019
Episode: 168
Live at the Civic Center in Des Moines
Karen and Georgia cover Tracey Richter and the Villisca Axe Murders.4
Apr 2019
Episode: 167
Bomb Grade
Karen and Georgia cover the death of Karen Silkwood and serial killer Sam Little.28
Mar 2019
Episode: 166
Respecting the History of Coins
Karen and Georgia cover the Cincinnati Who Stampede Concert and Glennon Engleman.21
Mar 2019
Episode: 165
Live at the Old National Centre in Indianapolis
Karen and Georgia cover the Richmond Hill explosion and the murder of Marjorie Jackson.14
Mar 2019
Episode: 164
Live at the Sony Centre in Toronto
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Julie Stanton and the Massey Maid Murder.7
Mar 2019
Episode: 163
Nine Cocaines
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Bob Crane and the Dexter Copycat Killer.28
Feb 2019
Episode: 162
Prom Queen City
Karen and Georgia cover murderer Mark "Gator" Rogowski and the murder of Jane Bashara.21
Feb 2019
Episode: 161
Live at the Blaisdell Concert Hall in Honolulu
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Yvonne Mathison and the Maui Yoga Twin case.14
Feb 2019
Episode: 160
Cynthia & Barry
Karen and Georgia cover the story of Eddie Aikau and the Sleepwalking Murderer.7
Feb 2019
Episode: 159
Live at the Lyric in Baltimore
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Carolyn Wasilewski and the Baltimore Plot.31
Jan 2019
Episode: 158
Burn Day
Karen and Georgia cover the 3 Billboards murder of Kathy Page and the San Ysidro McDonald's Massacre.24
Jan 2019
Episode: 157
Live at the Civic Theatre in San Diego
Karen and Georgia cover the Torrey Pines Beach Murders and the Rose Petal Murder.17
Jan 2019
Episode: 156
Mr. Cool & Nice - The Conan O'Brien Episode
Karen and Georgia sit down with Conan O'Brien to discuss his obsession with true crime. Header Image Source: Photo by Jacek Dylag on Unsplash10
Jan 2019
Episode: 155
You Don't Know What You Don't Know
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Su Taraskiewicz and Abraham Shakespeare.3
Jan 2019
Episode: 154
DNA Dad
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Thelma Todd and the Footpath Murders.20
Dec 2018
Episode: 152
Live at the O2 Academy in Glasgow
Karen and Georgia cover the Burke & Hare murders and the Bible John murders.13
Dec 2018
Episode: 151
Live at the Queen Elizabeth Theatre in Vancouver
Karen and Georgia cover the Abbotsford Killer and the Salish Sea human foot mystery.6
Dec 2018
Episode: 150
How Dare You Kelli
Karen and Georgia cover the hanging of Alice Riley and the murder of Reyna Marroquin.29
Nov 2018
Episode: 149
Lifestyle & Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Missoula Mauler and the Forest Park Killer.22
Nov 2018
Episode: 148
Live at the Community Center Theater in Sacramento
Karen and Georgia cover attempted assassin Squeaky Fromme and the Lodi Haystack Murder. Plus surprise guest Paul Holes.15
Nov 2018
Episode: 147
Live in Austin
Karen and Georgia cover Robert Elmer Kleason and the murder of Steven Robards.8
Nov 2018
Episode: 146
Dawna's Skinny Lighter
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Randy Mock and the Seattle Cyanide Poisonings.1
Nov 2018
Episode: 145
Live at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover the satanic panic of McMartin Pre-School and the Mannequin at the Carnival.25
Oct 2018
Episode: 144
Live at the Chevalier Theatre in Medford, MA
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of George Parkman and the Great Molasses Flood of 1919.18
Oct 2018
Episode: 143
Desabotage
Karen and Georgia cover the truth behind poisoned Halloween candy and the murder of Carol Stuart.11
Oct 2018
Episode: 142
Live at the Durham Performing Arts Center
Karen and Georgia cover the Lawson Family murders and the Bitter Blood murders.4
Oct 2018
Episode: 141
Big Thirsty Robe
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Heidi and Christine and the murder of Linda Bailey Brown.20
Sep 2018
Episode: 139
A Hundred Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Kunz Family Murders and the murder of Joan Dawley.13
Sep 2018
Episode: 138
Live at the Red Rocks Ballroom in Las Vegas
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Gerard Soules and the death of Ted Binion.6
Sep 2018
Episode: 137
Gloogle
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of BBC reporter Jill Dando and the Andrews’ Family ‘Hauntings.’30
Aug 2018
Episode: 136
The Uninhibited
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Stanford White and the case of the Boys on the Tracks.23
Aug 2018
Episode: 135
The Multiverse Trajectory
Karen and Georgia cover the Party Monster murder of Angel Melendez and the story of Clarence and Melinda Elkins.16
Aug 2018
Episode: 134
Live at the Connor Palace in Cleveland
Karen and Georgia cover Ed Edwards and the Kirtland cult killings.9
Aug 2018
Episode: 133
Made of Crystals
Karen and Georgia cover the Gainesville Ripper and the Lady of the Dunes.2
Aug 2018
Episode: 132
Awful Peanut
Karen and Georgia cover the cult of Synanon and the death of Azaria Chamberlain.27
Jul 2018
Episode: 131
Live at the Chinateatern in Stockholm
Karen and Georgia cover Nikita Bergenström and Sture Bergwall aka Thomas Quick.19
Jul 2018
Episode: 130
Mike is Right
Karen and Georgia cover the Fall of the Romanovs and Fred and Rosemary West.12
Jul 2018
Episode: 129
Coincidence Island
Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair.5
Jul 2018
Episode: 128
Live at Albert Hall in Manchester
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Mary Ann Britland and Trevor Hardy.28
Jun 2018
Episode: 127
Our Beautiful Rat King
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Angela Samota and Finland’s Lake Bodom murders.21
Jun 2018
Episode: 126
Nice Office
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Lawrence DeLisle and the murder of Kim Wall.14
Jun 2018
Episode: 125
Bedside Astrologer!
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Scott Johnston and Sean Farmer and the Glamour Girl Slayer.7
Jun 2018
Episode: 124
Errant Duct Tape
Karen and Georgia cover the unsolved crimes of Mr. Cruel and the murder of Girly Chew Hossencofft.31
May 2018
Episode: 123
Live at Vicar Street in Dublin
Karen and Georgia cover Colin Whelan and the Stoneybatter Strangler.10
May 2018
Episode: 120
Live at the Orpheum in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover LA crime journalist Agness Underwood and the Los Feliz Murder Mansion.3
May 2018
Episode: 119
Fingers Everywhere
Karen and Georgia cover the Lipstick Killer and the Lindbergh Baby kidnapping.26
Apr 2018
Episode: 118
Golden State Serial Killer Caught
Karen and Georgia cover the arrest of the Golden State Killer. Plus investigative journalist Billy Jensen calls in.19
Apr 2018
Episode: 117
Reality's Canceled
Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Teka Adams and the West Mesa Bone Collector.12
Apr 2018
Episode: 116
Robot Grandma
Karen and Georgia cover killers Jesse Pomeroy and Issei Sagawa.14
Jan 2016
Episode: 1
My Firstest Murder
In the very first episode, Karen and Georgia discuss car accidents, JonBenét Ramsey, and the Sacramento's East Area Rapist. Plus a local story from Feral Audio founder, Dustin Martian.
Listen
