All Episodes
Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.
30
Mar 2023
Episode: 372
Math with Karen & Georgia
On today’s episode, Georgia covers the tragic disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito and Karen covers the legendary story of Phineas P. Gage.28
Mar 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #87
In Mini Minisode 87, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shouts out the children of divorce and Karen narrates hide and seek gone wrong.23
Mar 2023
Episode: 371
Upset at the Air
This week, Karen covers the fight for justice for the murders of Henry Dee and Charles Moore and Georgia covers the mysterious Lead Masks Case.21
Mar 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #86
In Mini Minisode 86, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells of a grandpa and his buried traysure and Georgia details an innovative meet cute strategy.16
Mar 2023
Episode: 370
Necessary Yelling
This week, Georgia covers "The Bandit Queen" Pearl Hart and Karen tells the Mount St. Helens eruption survival story of Dave Crockett.14
Mar 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #85
In Mini Minisode 85, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia presents a bank teller’s most memorable task and Karen narrates the time a trash dad took the kids fishing.9
Mar 2023
Episode: 369
Blizzard Hotline
On today’s episode, Karen covers the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre and Georgia tells the story of the murder of Nicole van den Hurk.7
Mar 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #84
In Mini Minisode 84, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a listener tale about a little girl named Faye who could see monsters and Karen's story centers around Sam and a poorly maintained porch.2
Mar 2023
Episode: 368
Sharp Elbows
This week, Georgia covers the 2004 Napa Halloween murders of Adriane Insogna and Leslie Mazzara and Karen tells the story of Jacques Grelley and the 1955 Le Mans motor race disaster.28
Feb 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #83
In Mini Minisode 83, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen passes along some examples of Italian superstition and Georgia reads a listener letter about an amazing Nana named Kay who had a perchance for sewing.23
Feb 2023
Episode: 367
High-Fives With Both Hands
This week, Karen covers the missing persons case of Donald Boardman and Georgia tells the story of the "Missing Boy of Somosierra,” Juan Pedro Martínez Gómez.21
Feb 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #82
In Mini Minisode 82, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia warns of a stoner’s mistake and Karen has a tale from the mailroom.16
Feb 2023
Episode: 366
High-Pitched Goodbye
This week, Georgia tells the story of the Mirabal sisters, heroes of the Dominican Republic, and Karen covers Cleveland's infamous 1974 Ten Cent Beer Night.14
Feb 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #81
In Mini Minisode 81, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen serves up a classic sinkhole story and Georgia has a 1930s parenting survivor story.9
Feb 2023
Episode: 365
You Don’t Ever Know
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia cover Theodore Durrant, aka the "Demon of the Belfry" and the ghost ship, the Mary Celeste.7
Feb 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #80
In Mini Minisode 80, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia pays homage to a bird icon and Karen tells the tale of heroic stoners.2
Feb 2023
Episode: 364
The B-I
This week, Georgia tells the story of William H. Wallace and the murder of his wife, Julia Wallace, and Karen covers the legendary Ma Barker.31
Jan 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #79
In Mini Minisode 79, Karen and Georgia tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen shares a disdain for tomatoes and Georgia details a baby memory.26
Jan 2023
Episode: 363
Landed In Marshmallows
On today’s episode, Karen covers the life and mysterious death of Harry Houdini and Georgia tells the puzzling story of Brandon Swanson's disappearance.24
Jan 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #78
In Mini Minisode 78, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia narrates a breakfast mishap and Karen reminds you to check your kids lunchbox.19
Jan 2023
Episode: 362
A Generous Number of Apples
This week, Georgia covers the "Boy in the Box" case and Karen tells the legend of Cuba's first Olympic marathoner, Felix de la Caridad Carvajal.17
Jan 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #77
In Mini Minisode 77, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen demonstrates the worst way to be woken up and Georgia tells of a claustrophobic experience.12
Jan 2023
Episode: 361
The Opportunist
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen are joined by Hannah Smith, the host of the podcast The Opportunist, to tell the story of Sandra Anderson and her dog, Eagle. Note: The book Karen mentioned in today's episode is "Finder: The True Story of a Private Investigator" by Marilyn Greene and Gary Provost.10
Jan 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #76
In Mini Minisode 76, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen details an act of sibling injustice and Georgia explains why you should never trust kids.5
Jan 2023
Episode: 360
Inner Mother
On this week's episode, Georgia tells Karen about the mysterious death of scientist Rodney Marks in Antarctica.3
Jan 2023
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #75
In Mini Minisode 75, Georgia and Karen tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia has a sweet gift exchange and Karen shares a tribute to an Easter-loving aunt.29
Dec 2022
Episode: 359
We Wish You A Merry Criminal
This week, Karen and Georgia welcome back Phoebe Judge, the host of Criminal, to tell the story of the Sodder children's disappearance on Christmas Eve.27
Dec 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #74
In Mini Minisode 74, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia introduces us to Party Barb and Party Tom and Karen reminds you to hug your mom.22
Dec 2022
Episode: 358
A Socially Awkward Person's Great Idea
This week, Karen tells Georgia the horrible story of serial abuser and convicted murderer Shelly Knotek.20
Dec 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #73
In Mini Minisode 73, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia presents a family's superstitions and Karen explains why we don’t trust handsome men.15
Dec 2022
Episode: 357
The Big Exhale
On this week’s episode, Georgia tells Karen about the mysterious disappearance of Malaysia Airlines Flight 370.13
Dec 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #72
In Mini Minisode 72, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia proves the importance of cleaning out your car and Karen presents a childhood camp adventure.8
Dec 2022
Episode: 356
Tugboat of Life
This week, Karen tells Georgia the rescue and survival story of Harrison Okene.6
Dec 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #71
In Mini Minisode 71, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen narrates a heartwarming meet cute and Georgia introduces a traysure of a long lost relative.1
Dec 2022
Episode: 355
Satanic Panic Attack
This week, Georgia tells Karen the story of Arne Cheyenne Johnson and the "Demon Murder Trial."29
Nov 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #70
In Mini Minisode 70, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen describes the gates of hell and Georgia presents a terrible teenage job.24
Nov 2022
Episode: 354
Heist You Up
This week, Georgia tells Karen the story of Heather Tallchief and one of the largest Vegas heists in history.22
Nov 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #69
In Mini Minisode 69, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details the most awkward setup ever and Karen reminds us how traumatic 2020 was.17
Nov 2022
Episode: 353
I Said No Gifts!
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia are joined by the hilarious host of I Said No Gifts!, Bridger Winegar, for a chat about holiday gift giving.15
Nov 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #68
In Mini Minisode 68, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details a long running prank and Karen makes you weary of April Fool’s Day.10
Nov 2022
Episode: 352
Serve The Children
This week, Karen tells Georgia the story of church leader Gwen Shamblin Lara.8
Nov 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #67
In Mini Minisode 67, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen narrates a child’s late night barn mission and Georgia introduces Steven’s new nickname.3
Nov 2022
Episode: 351
High-Five Halloween
On today's Halloween episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Great Famine of 1315 and the history of the mummy trade.1
Nov 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #66
In Mini Minisode 66, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen details a traumatic job interview and Georgia describes Karen’s worst nightmare.27
Oct 2022
Episode: 350
My Favorite Murdaugh
This week, Karen and Georgia chat with the hosts of the Murdaugh Murders Podcast, Mandy Matney and Liz Farrell.25
Oct 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #65
In Mini Minisode 65, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia presents the ultimate thrift store find and Karen makes a strong case to take your birth control.20
Oct 2022
Episode: 349
A Bit of Stew
This week, Georgia tells Karen about Dr. Max Jacobson, aka “Dr. Feelgood,” and his lethal vitamin shots.18
Oct 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #64
In Mini Minisode 64, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details a glitch in the matrix and Karen raises concern over a questionable contract.13
Oct 2022
Episode: 348
Old Biscuit
This week, Karen tells Georgia the survival story of the Titanic's baker, Charles Joughin.11
Oct 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #63
In Mini Minisode 63, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen has a hot tip for getting out of jury duty and Georgia narrates a rabies tale.6
Oct 2022
Episode: 347
Hello and Welcome, It’s Billy Eichner
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia chat with the star and co-writer of the gay romantic comedy Bros, Billy Eichner.4
Oct 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #62
In Mini Minisode 62, Karen and Georgia tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen shares a compilation of requested minisode topics and Georgia tells us about a perfectly executed prank.29
Sep 2022
Episode: 346
Fistful of Butter
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen cover serial killer Robert Garrow and the Japanese doomsday cult Aum Shinrikyo.27
Sep 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #61
In Mini Minisode 61, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia has a troublemaker pet tale and Karen reinforces the benefits of renters insurance.22
Sep 2022
Episode: 345
Congrats to Australia
This week, Karen covers the murder of Carol Jenkins and Georgia breaks down the investigation surrounding the Ford Pinto car.20
Sep 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #60
In Mini Minisode 60, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen finds the perfect location for her second wedding and Georgia tells of a 1960s motel mishap.15
Sep 2022
Episode: 344
Hypothetical Rearview Mirror
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the mysterious death of Marilyn Monroe and the survival story of Brazilian pilot Antonio Sena.13
Sep 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #59
In Mini Minisode 59, Georgia and Karen tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares a precious grandpa secret and Karen narrates a terrifying summer night.8
Sep 2022
Episode: 343
This Is Buried Bones
This week, Kate Winkler Dawson and Paul Holes of Exactly Right's newest podcast, Buried Bones, join Karen and Georgia to cover the 1933 death of Allene Lamson.6
Sep 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #58
In Mini Minisode 58, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details an accidental pepper spray and Karen reminds us not to trust a five-year old.1
Sep 2022
Episode: 342
The Debras of the World
On today's episode, Karen tells the story of Stuart Alexander, another murderous "Sausage King" and Georgia covers the disappearance of the Death Valley Germans.30
Aug 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #57
In Mini Minisode 57, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen narrates a boating mishap and Georgia pays homage to a trash dad.25
Aug 2022
Episode: 341
If You Were Godzilla…
This week, Georgia covers the disappearance of Jennifer Dulos and Karen tells the story of the strip search scam behind the film “Compliance.”23
Aug 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #56
In Mini Minisode 56, Karen and Georgia tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen spills some grandma tea and Georgia shares some vet drama.18
Aug 2022
Episode: 340
Catfish Your Friends
On today’s episode, Karen covers the murder of Milly Dowler and Georgia tells the story of Ervil LeBaron, the “Mormon Manson.”16
Aug 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #55
In Mini Minisode 55, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details a trip almost gone wrong and Karen tells of an Australian sinkhole.11
Aug 2022
Episode: 339
Grab Your Chapstick
This week, Georgia tells the mysterious story of the 1989 Mount Asahidake SOS incident and Karen covers the 1964 Alaska earthquake.9
Aug 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #54
In Mini Minisode 54, Georgia and Karen tell two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia reminds us to lock our doors and Karen shares an iconic meet cute.4
Aug 2022
Episode: 338
We Saw What You Did
Karen and Georgia are joined by the hosts of I Saw What You Did, Millie De Chirico and Danielle Henderson, to discuss the Al Pacino classic, “Dog Day Afternoon.”2
Aug 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #53
In Mini Minisode 53, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen narrates a drunk child story and Georgia offers excellent fashion advice.28
Jul 2022
Episode: 337
A Survival Story with Kara Robinson Chamberlain
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen are joined by survivor and activist, Kara Robinson Chamberlain.26
Jul 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #52
In Mini Minisode 52, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia reminds us to listen to our gut and Karen unlocks a new fear.21
Jul 2022
Episode: 336
The FBI with Jerri Williams
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen interview former FBI special agent, Jerri Williams.18
Jul 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #51
In Mini Minisode 51, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells a lighthearted tale about getting run over by dad and Georgia demonstrates the power that comes from owning a metal bat.14
Jul 2022
Episode: 335
Black and Missing with Natalie and Derrica Wilson
This week, Karen and Georgia talk with the founders of the Black and Missing Foundation, Natalie and Derrica Wilson.12
Jul 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #50
In Mini Minisode 50, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia narrates a Smithsonian visit gone wrong and Karen gives an Australian phone booth update.7
Jul 2022
Episode: 334
2,000 Pounds of Soap
This week, Karen tells the story of murderer Adolph Luetgert, Chicago’s “Sausage King” and Georgia covers the mysterious disappearance of Laureen Rahn.5
Jul 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #49
In Mini Minisode 49, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia details a broken window mystery and Karen makes you reminisce over the ball pits at Discovery Zone.30
Jun 2022
Episode: 333
Spiritual Brag
This week, Georgia covers the mysterious disappearance of Jean Spangler and Karen tells the story of Colton Harris-Moore, the "Barefoot Bandit.”28
Jun 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #48
In Mini Minisode 48, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen brings the mylar balloons back and Georgia tells of a lighthearted bank robbery.23
Jun 2022
Episode: 332
I’m Phoebe Judge
On today's episode, Phoebe Judge tells Georgia and Karen the story of Northeast Airlines Flight 823.21
Jun 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #47
In Mini Minisode 47, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan cult. Georgia details a Murderino’s childhood and Karen makes you want to hug a dog.16
Jun 2022
Episode: 331
Hermetic Lifestyles
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the devastating Tri-State Tornado of 1925 and the Buenos Aires bank heist of 2006.14
Jun 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #46
In Mini Minisode 46, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells the story of Sarah Ellen the Vampiress and Georgia makes us weary of our neighbors.9
Jun 2022
Episode: 330
The Thing About Keith Morrison
This week, Georgia and Karen are joined by award-winning correspondent and podcast host, Keith Morrison. [Header Image Source: Photo by Matthias Wagner on Unsplash]7
Jun 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #45
In Mini Minisode 45, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia makes you terrified of your childhood toys and Karen narrates a dramatic acid trip.2
Jun 2022
Episode: 329
The Last Telephone Booth
This week, Georgia covers the murder of Lisa Kimmell and the Great Basin Serial Killer and Karen tells the story of Larry Ray, the "Sarah Lawrence dorm dad."31
May 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #44
In Mini Minisode 44, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a petty squirrel tale and Karen details an act of kindness from a stranger.26
May 2022
Episode: 328
The Year is 2243
On today’s episode, Karen covers the death of socialite Sunny von Bülow and Georgia tells more stories of bodies found in chimneys. Note: this episode was recorded before the horrific tragedy in Uvalde, Texas.24
May 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #43
In Mini Minisode 43, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia narrates a trick-or-treat adventure and Karen spills the office tea.19
May 2022
Episode: 327
Double Mylar
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the disappearance of the Yuba County Five and the tragic Clydach murders.17
May 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #42
In Mini Minisode 42, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week includes advice for living alone and James Brown.12
May 2022
Episode: 326
Don’t Ask Tig Notaro
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen welcome comedian Tig Notaro, host of the podcast Don't Ask Tig, to tell her hometown story.10
May 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #41
In Mini Minisode 41, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen creeps us out with a sex education experience and Georgia tells a drunk baby tale.5
May 2022
Episode: 325
Major Awards
This week, Karen and Georgia cover Ron Jones and “The Third Wave” social experiment and the disappearance and death of Robert Thompson.3
May 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #40
In Mini Minisode 40, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan cult. Georgia details a first grader’s most embarrassing moment and Karen gives a serotonin boost with the adventure of Chirp.28
Apr 2022
Episode: 324
Hit That Mute Button
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen cover the tragic disappearance of Kelsey Collins and the miraculous survival of Captain Tim Lancaster on British Airways Flight 5390.26
Apr 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #39
In Mini Minisode 39, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells a scammer tale and Georgia shares a touching story from a survivor.21
Apr 2022
Episode: 323
Pills & Thrills
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the "National Forest Serial Killer" Gary Michael Hilton and the mysterious disappearance of Judy Smith.19
Apr 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #38
In Mini Minisode 38, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia covers a forbidden love story and Karen details a Murderino’s famous family.14
Apr 2022
Episode: 322
Tenfold More Murder: Part 2
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia welcome back Kate Winkler Dawson to continue the story of serial killer John Reginald Christie.12
Apr 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #37
In Mini Minisode 37, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen details a sock drawer snoop and Georgia takes us through a rollercoaster of emotions over a dwarf hamster.7
Apr 2022
Episode: 321
Tenfold More Murder: Part 1
On today's episode, Kate Winkler Dawson tells Georgia and Karen the story of serial killer John Reginald Christie.5
Apr 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #36
In Mini Minisode 36, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia describes a princess adventure and Karen warms the heart with a ghost story.30
Mar 2022
Episode: 320
Gurl, Slow Down
This week, Georgia and Karen cover "Grindr Killer" Stephen Port and the survival story of Joe Simpson and Simon Yates in the Peruvian Andes.29
Mar 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #35
In Mini Minisode 35, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week includes a party with a murder suspect and a grandma named Arlene.24
Mar 2022
Episode: 319
Horse Camp
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the Cokeville Elementary School bombing and the abduction of Kari Swenson.22
Mar 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #34
In Mini Minisode 34, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a tattle's tale and Karen narrates a joy ride.17
Mar 2022
Episode: 318
One Spiritual Moment
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen cover the shooting of Nicholas Green and the 1971 Nashville plane hijacking.15
Mar 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #33
In Mini Minisode 33, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen explains what happens when you marry a former Eagle Scout and Georgia details the time a listener was followed.10
Mar 2022
Episode: 317
Hello and Welcome to Disgraceland
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia welcome Jake Brennan, host of the podcast Disgraceland, to tell his hometown story.7
Mar 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #32
In Mini Minisode 32, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares a listener’s Italian fiasco and Karen details what happens when a kid is put in charge.3
Mar 2022
Episode: 316
Circle of Malice
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the attempted murder of Mary Jo Buttafuoco and the Box Lady of Benton County.28
Feb 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #31
In Mini Minisode 31, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a story of mistaken identity and Karen shares how a listener’s mom stayed sexy and didn’t get murdered.24
Feb 2022
Episode: 315
Here Be Monsters!
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the Gypsy Hill killings and the cruise ship survival story of Moss and Tracy Hills.21
Feb 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #30
In Mini Minisode 30, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia’s story dives into a cult and Karen’s boasts about a badass with killer instinct.17
Feb 2022
Episode: 314
The Chip Away Method
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Hartford circus fire and the murders of Ashley Pond and Miranda Gaddis.14
Feb 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #29
In Mini Minisode 29, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen retells a ouija board horror and Georgia tells a tale about a shitty kid.10
Feb 2022
Episode: 313
This is Criminal
On today's episode, Phoebe Judge tells Karen and Georgia the shocking story of Pearl Lusk and Olga Rocco.7
Feb 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #28
In Mini Minisode 28, Karen and Georgia tug at the heartstrings with two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a story about a pumpkin and Karen shares how a listener almost killed.3
Feb 2022
Episode: 312
Ad Infinitum
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the kidnapping of Jody Plauché and the life of Bessie Coleman.31
Jan 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #27
In Mini Minisode 27, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia reads a tale about an all-star mall hairstylist who saved a living room wedding and Karen shares a personal I SURVIVED story from a listener.27
Jan 2022
Episode: 311
Challenge Practice
On today's episode, Karen covers the murder of Charles de Young and Georgia covers the mysterious locked-room murder of Greg Fleniken.24
Jan 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #26
In Mini Minisode 26, Georgia and Karen read two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares a story about a fur coat-wearing talent scout and Karen retells a listener tale about a beloved protector named Levi.20
Jan 2022
Episode: 310
I Like Seagulls
On today’s episode, Georgia and Karen cover the Attica prison uprising and the survival of José Salvador Alvarenga.17
Jan 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #25
In Mini Minisode 25, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen shares a story about an aunt's murderous high school sweetheart and Georgia reads a hometown from a listener who's dad got his ass stuck in a wall.13
Jan 2022
Episode: 309
Not Counting Is The Key: The 6th Anniversary Special!
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Aundria Bowman and the history of the insanity defense.10
Jan 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #24
In Mini Minisode 24, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen's epic story is about a child's past life in Tulsa and Georgia tells a listener tale about a sister's attempted murder via peanut allergy.6
Jan 2022
Episode: 308
A Blur of Entertainment
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the stories of Blanche Monnier and Candy Mossler.3
Jan 2022
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #23
In Mini Minisode 23, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares the origin story of a Murderino whose teacher overshared about jury duty. Karen retells a listener's story about poor parental decisions and some heroic Australians.30
Dec 2021
Episode: 307
Fun Cracker Reveal
On today's episode, Karen covers the Miracle in the Andes: the Uruguayan Flight 571 crash, and Georgia tells the story of Celia Cooney, the Bobbed Haired Bandit.29
Dec 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Megan Mullally
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Megan Mullally.27
Dec 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #22
In Mini Minisode 22, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen's story is a great one about how a 14-year-old got a group of medical professionals drunk at a holiday party. Georgia shares the tale of a listener who caught her little brother inhaling whipped cream.23
Dec 2021
Episode: 306
Present Blitz
This week, Georgia covers the mysterious death of Blair Adams and Karen tells the story of "Love Has Won" cult leader, Amy Carlson.22
Dec 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Nick Offerman
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Nick Offerman.20
Dec 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #21
In Mini Minisode 21, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells a story of a mother's life-saving intuition and Georgia shares a listener's best-case scenario while wearing a towel story.16
Dec 2021
Episode: 305
You Heard It Here Last
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Amanda Milan and the Toronto Circus Riot of 1855.15
Dec 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Phoebe Bridgers
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Phoebe Bridgers.13
Dec 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #20
In Mini Minisode 20, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a listener story of someone getting a baby drunk and Karen's story of Roman cokes ruining Christmas.9
Dec 2021
Episode: 304
Show-Off Time
This week, Georgia covers the life and tragic death of Aaliyah and Karen tells the survival story of ultramarathon runner Mauro Prosperi.8
Dec 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Nicole Byer
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Nicole Byer.6
Dec 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #19
In Mini Minisode 19, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, Georgia's story is a tale of neighborly murder and Karen offers a great story about a kid denying the identity of her dad at daycare.2
Dec 2021
Episode: 303
The Lansburys & The Greystones
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the deadly green arsenic dresses of Victorian England and the recently solved cold case of Kaitlyn Arquette.1
Dec 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Margaret Cho
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Margaret Cho.29
Nov 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #18
In Mini Minisode 18, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, both stories revolve around the scattering of cremains - one accidentally and one secretly.25
Nov 2021
Episode: 302
Whistles & Flags
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen cover the mystery of Havana Syndrome and the murder of Martha Brailsford.24
Nov 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Wanda Sykes
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Wanda Sykes.18
Nov 2021
Episode: 301
A Place For Moms
On today’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Paul Martin Andrews and the unsolved murder of E.C. Mullendore III.17
Nov 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Patton Oswalt
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Patton Oswalt.11
Nov 2021
Episode: 300
The 300th Episode!
On the 300th episode of My Favorite Murder, Georgia and Karen cover the case of Patty Stallings and the story of the Chippendales murder.10
Nov 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #17
In Mini Minisode 17, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a lost car and a burly ally in a late-night parking garage and a haunted bath robe on fire.10
Nov 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Paul Holes
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is crime fighter turned podcaster, Paul Holes.4
Nov 2021
Episode: 299
London & England
On today's episode, Karen covers Scottish serial killer Dennis Nilsen and Georgia tells the story of Detective Jack Whicher and the Road Hill House murder.3
Nov 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Michelle Buteau
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest comedian Michelle Buteau.3
Nov 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #16
In Mini Minisode 16, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a tricky little spirit in a house and an extremely terrible Halloween prank.28
Oct 2021
Episode: 298
Feelings In Real Time
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the mysterious death of Edgar Allan Poe and the harrowing case of Cyntoia Brown.28
Oct 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #15
In Mini Minisode 15, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a very bad bank manager and a New Hampshire-based relative of H. H. Holmes the 19th century American serial killer.27
Oct 2021
Celebrity Hometowns: Josh Mankiewicz
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Josh Mankiewicz of NBC's Dateline.21
Oct 2021
Episode: 297
Lick the Difference!
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Sharon Shaw and Rhonda "Renee" Johnson and the history of the Miranda rights.21
Oct 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #14
In Mini Minisode 14, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a real-life The Orphan and the twisted tale of a Denver cemetery relocation.14
Oct 2021
Episode: 296
Stakeouts & Balloons
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the unsolved cases of three Indigenous women, Kiana Klomp, Amber Tuccaro, and Ella Mae Begay, and the disappearance of Lawrence Joseph Bader.14
Oct 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #13
In Mini Minisode 13 (they're back!), Georgia and Karen do two extra hometown stories. In this episode, the gals share the insane story of purposeful poisonings and an aunt's beloved octopus ring.7
Oct 2021
Episode: 295
Twenty-Two To Go
On today's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Hinterkaifeck murders and the history of the lie detector.30
Sep 2021
Episode: 294
Was It A Sandwich?
On this week's episode, Georgia and Karen cover the Hillsborough disaster and the story of the Lindow Woman bog body.29
Sep 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #12
In Mini Minisode 12 (they're back!), Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a hostage negotiator father and an anti-racist family who doles out KKK clap backs!23
Sep 2021
Episode: 293
Did We Forget Canada?
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the stories of the Rosewood massacre and hero Oliver "Billy" Sipple.22
Sep 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #11
In Mini Minisode 11 (they're back!), Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a gallows-collecting Texan dad and latch key kid with a vigilant Swedish father.16
Sep 2021
Episode: 292
All Coffee & Apple Pie
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the cold case murders of Barbara Oberholtzer and Annette Schnee and the mysterious disappearance of the Candy Lady, Helen Brach.9
Sep 2021
Episode: 291
Welcome to the Comfort Zone
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the murders committed by Ed Buck and the story of drowning victim recovery experts, Gene and Sandy Ralston.2
Sep 2021
Episode: 290
Full Metal Recovery
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the stories of Nazi resistance fighter Irena Sendler and the Welsh crate man, Brian Robson.26
Aug 2021
Episode: 289
MFM Guest Host Picks #12 - Nick Terry
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Nick Terry, creator of MFM Animated (youtube.com/exactlyrightmedia). Nick covers Stories of People Buried Alive (Episode 186) and the story of The Mothman Legend & Silver Bridge Collapse (Episode 183).19
Aug 2021
Episode: 288
MFM Guest Host Picks #11 - Erin & Erin
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Erin & Erin, hosts of This Podcast Will Kill You on Exactly Right. The Erins cover the stories of The Incredible Survival of Jennifer Morey (Episode 33) and The Tragic Death of Mitrice Richardson (Episode 65).12
Aug 2021
Episode: 287
MFM Guest Host Picks #10: Kate Winkler Dawson
his summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Kate Winkler Dawson, host of Tenfold More Wicked and Wicked Words on Exactly Right. Kate covers the stories of The Murder of Irene Garza (Episode 99) and Fred and Rosemary West (Episode 130).5
Aug 2021
Episode: 286
MFM Guest Host Picks #9: Bridger Winegar
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Bridger Winegar, host of I Said No Gifts! on Exactly Right. Bridger covers The Murders of Master Forger Mark Hofmann (Episode 76) and The Sleepwalking Murderer (Episode 160).29
Jul 2021
Episode: 285
MFM Guest Host Picks #8: Kyle Russell (kikiwithkiki)
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by content creator Kyle Russell (kikiwithkiki), one of social media’s favorite Karen and Georgia lip syncers. Kyle shares the stories of the Amityville Horror Murders (Episode 90) and the Lindbergh Baby Kidnapping (Episode 119).22
Jul 2021
Episode: 284
MFM Guest Host Picks #7: Kara Klenk
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Kara Klenk, co-host of That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast on Exactly Right. Kara covers the stories of Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka (Episode 91), Joseph Edward Duncan III (Episode 63), and a special hometown (Episode 16).15
Jul 2021
Episode: 283
MFM Guest Host Picks #6: Danielle Henderson
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Danielle Henderson, co-host of I Saw What You Did on Exactly Right. Danielle shares the stories of Who Put Bella in the Wych Elm? (Episode 10) and Lord Lucan (Episode 45).8
Jul 2021
Episode: 282
MFM Guest Host Picks #5: Scotty Landes
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Scotty Landes, co-host of Bananas on Exactly Right. Scotty covers the stories of the Oakland County Child Killer (Episode 3) and the Martha Moxley Murder Case (Episode 5).1
Jul 2021
Episode: 281
MFM Guest Host Picks #4: Brandie Posey
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Brandie Posey, co-host of Lady to Lady on Exactly Right. Brandie shares the stories of the Fort Worth Three Kidnapping and John Wayne Gacy (Live from the Chicago Podcast Festival - Episode 44).24
Jun 2021
Episode: 280
MFM Guest Host Picks #3: Billy Jensen
This week’s MFM’s Guest Host Pick features Billy Jensen from JENSEN & HOLES: THE MURDER SQUAD. Billy introduces us to two of his favorite stories from past episodes of My Favorite Murder. From Episode 163 on March 7, 2019, Georgia covers Mark Twitchell, the Dexter Copycat Killer. And Karen’s story of the murder of Bonnie Lee Bakley is from Episode 112 from March 15, 2018.17
Jun 2021
Episode: 279
MFM Guest Host Picks #2: Elizabeth Taylor
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Elizabeth Taylor — host of The True Beauty Brooklyn Podcast on Exactly Right — covering the stories of the Tulsa Race Massacre (Episode 211) and the Murder of Angie Dodge (Episode 185).10
Jun 2021
Episode: 278
MFM Guest Host Picks #1: Steven Ray Morris
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia. Today's episode is hosted by Steven Ray Morris—MFM audio engineer and host of The Purrrcast—covering the stories of Selena (Episode 32) and The Lady of the Dunes (Episode 133).9
Jun 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #10
In Mini Minisode 10, Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a terrible doctor who was not to be trusted and a mysterious vibration.3
Jun 2021
Episode: 277
Live at the Fox Theater in Detroit, MI (2019)
On this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Rattle Run Church murder and the murder of Tina Biggar.2
Jun 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #9
In Mini Minisode 9, Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a nearly murderous roller coaster and a dare involving a car's cigarette lighter.27
May 2021
Episode: 276
Live at Vicar Street in Dublin (2018)
On this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive, Karen and Georgia cover murderers Colin Howell and Catherine Nevin.26
May 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #8
Welcome to Mini Minisode 8, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear about a toddler with a fascination with electricity and a couple of murderous neighbors.20
May 2021
Episode: 275
Raise The Snail: Steven’s 5th Anniversary!
This week, Karen and Georgia tell the story of the real life "Lord of the Flies.”19
May 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #7
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's stories include an unlocked door after a rough night and a haunted chemistry lab.13
May 2021
Episode: 274
Arrested Behavior
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Laci Peterson.12
May 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #6
Welcome to Mini Minisode 6, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear about a mishap at a Christian college and a surprise panic button.6
May 2021
Episode: 273
Live at the Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall in Portland (2018)
On this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover murderer Christian Longo and the KOIN Tower hostage situation.5
May 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #5
Welcome to Mini Minisode 5, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear the story about delayed justice in small-town New Jersey and an unwelcome visitor during a well-deserved nap.29
Apr 2021
Episode: 272
BYOF
In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover The Beast of Birkenshaw and the mysterious legend of D.B. Cooper.28
Apr 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #4
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's story include a maxed out backpack and a possessed vibrator.22
Apr 2021
Episode: 271
4 Hours of Sacred Pausing
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover Sophie Scholl & the White Rose youth resistance, and the survival story of Ada Blackjack.21
Apr 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #3
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's stories include dump truck drama and a student driver rundown.15
Apr 2021
Episode: 270
Three Out Of Ten
On this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Brides in the Bath Murders and the case of Pam Hupp.14
Apr 2021
Fancult Exclusive
Mini Minisode #2
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week’s stories include a 4-year old savior and a fatherly encounter with an escaped inmate.8
Apr 2021
Episode: 269
Big Hot C'mon
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover spontaneous human combustion and the Paris Is Burning murders.7
Apr 2021
Fancult Exclusive
MFM Mini-Minisode #1
For your ears only, Karen and Georgia are doing one extra hometown story per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. The premiere episode of the Mini Minisode includes a scary parking structure story from the 70s and the continuation of the ball pit saga.1
Apr 2021
Episode: 268
All-Stars Of 7th Grade
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover The Poet of Wichita and the true story of the ‘Cocaine Bear.’25
Mar 2021
Episode: 267
Leg Show
On this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Adolphus Hotel Ghosts and the Bunnyman Legend.18
Mar 2021
Episode: 266
Rave After Rave
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Ruthie Mae McCoy and the life of Detective Jacklean Davis.11
Mar 2021
Episode: 265
The Answer’s Salt
On this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survivor story of Theresa Saldana.4
Mar 2021
Episode: 264
Goodbye, Sloppy Joe!
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murders at White House Farm.25
Feb 2021
Episode: 263
Let Me Challenge You
On this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Brown’s Chicken Massacre and Peggy Jo Tallas.18
Feb 2021
Episode: 262
Live at the Civic Theatre in San Diego, CA (2019)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the San Diego Tank Rampage and the murder of Don Hardin.11
Feb 2021
Episode: 261
What's Cookin'?
On this week’s episode, we cover the life of Eugene Bullard.4
Feb 2021
Episode: 260
Unwashed & Unabashed
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Lana Clarkson by Phil Spector.28
Jan 2021
Episode: 259
Fake Snow In Glendale
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the history of lobotomies and the Smuttynose Axe Murders.21
Jan 2021
Episode: 258
Abject Failure (2016)
On this re-airing of the post-2016 election episode, Karen and Georgia read Amazon product reviews and your hometowns.14
Jan 2021
Episode: 257
Monster Machine
In this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the revenge of Miriam Rodríguez and the Happy Face Killer.7
Jan 2021
Episode: 256
Live at the Fillmore in Detroit, MI (2017)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the death of Robin Boes and murderer Lowell Amos.31
Dec 2020
Episode: 255
Live at the Chevalier Theater in Medford, MA - Late Show (2018)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover Lizzie Borden and Eastern Air Lines Shuttle Flight 1320.24
Dec 2020
Episode: 254
Little Bandit & Pirate George
On this week's quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Lori Ann Auker and The Donner Party.17
Dec 2020
Episode: 253
Live at the Arvest Bank Theatre in Kansas City (2017)
In this week’s former Fan Cult exclusive episode, Karen and Georgia cover the Death of Bethany Deaton and Ray & Faye Copeland.10
Dec 2020
Episode: 252
The Great La-Z-Boy Uprising: Advice Q&A
This week, Karen and Georgia lend their amateur advice to your low-stakes problems.3
Dec 2020
Episode: 251
One Vince Away
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the ‘Starlight Tours’ aka the ‘Saskatoon Freezing Deaths.’26
Nov 2020
Episode: 250
Look Who’s Crossing
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Sherri Rasmussen.19
Nov 2020
Episode: 249
Clear of Debris
In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Lavinia Fisher and murderer Byron David Smith.12
Nov 2020
Episode: 248
Congratulations, Smarty
In this week's episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Kara Robinson Chamberlain and the University of Alabama Huntsville shooting.5
Nov 2020
Episode: 247
Champions In Our Own Ways
In this week’s quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Mary Vincent and the case of Typhoid Mary.29
Oct 2020
Episode: 246
thanks for the lolz
On this week’s episode, Karen and Georgia cover the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing and The California Witch Killers.22
Oct 2020
Episode: 245
Time Is Becoming A Serious Problem
Karen and Georgia cover the Pied Piper of Tucson.15
Oct 2020
Episode: 244
Be Nostalgic For Old Problems
Karen and Georgia cover the Claremont Serial Killer.8
Oct 2020
Episode: 243
New Escape Room
Karen and Georgia cover the I-5 Killer and the murder of Carol Thompson.1
Oct 2020
Episode: 242
Spoilerama
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Adam Walsh and the aftermath of the case.24
Sep 2020
Episode: 241
A Deep Pause
Karen and Georgia cover the Élan School and the Martha Moxley murder.17
Sep 2020
Episode: 240
Flapper Bob
In this quilt episode, Karen and Georgia cover Coney Island deaths and serial killer Andrew Cunanan.10
Sep 2020
Episode: 239
Expert Conversation: David Rudolf & Sonya Pfeiffer
Karen and Georgia chat with defense attorneys David Rudolf and Sonya Pfeiffer about The Staircase documentary and their new podcast, Abuse of Power.3
Sep 2020
Episode: 238
Lady Suit
Karen and Georgia cover the Ayahuasca murders and the Beast of Gévaudan.27
Aug 2020
Episode: 237
Anti-Hype Man
Karen and Georgia cover the wickedest woman in America, Patty Cannon, and the unsolved murder of civil rights pioneer Alberta Jones.20
Aug 2020
Episode: 236
Like A Quilt
Karen and Georgia cover the Old Exchange and Provost Dungeon, and Stull Cemetery.13
Aug 2020
Episode: 235
Mr. Zip
Karen and Georgia cover serial killer Robert Spangler and the unsolved Delphi murders.6
Aug 2020
Episode: 234
Diane Steele: The Q&A
Karen and Georgia answer your summertime questions in quarantine.30
Jul 2020
Episode: 233
Free Range Children
Karen and Georgia cover the Zoot Suit Riots and the 1976 Chowchilla bus kidnapping.23
Jul 2020
Episode: 232
Live at De Meervaart in Amsterdam (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover Willem van Eijk and Elsje Christiaens.16
Jul 2020
Episode: 231
Small Bigfoot
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Michael Jordan’s father, James R. Jordan Sr.9
Jul 2020
Episode: 230
The Tide Pools of Your Life
Karen and Georgia cover the Grim Sleeper.2
Jul 2020
Episode: 229
Live at the Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall in Portland (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Larry Peyton and Beverly Allan, and Edmund Creffield and the Brides of Christ Church aka the Holy Rollers.25
Jun 2020
Episode: 228
The Season Of The Abyss
Karen and Georgia cover the St. Francis Dam Disaster and the kidnapping of Elizabeth Shoaf.18
Jun 2020
Episode: 227
Live at the Belk Theater in Charlotte (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Marcus Shrader and Blanche Taylor Moore.11
Jun 2020
Episode: 226
50 Hour Days
Karen and Georgia cover the Hart Family murder/suicide and the murder of Stephen Lawrence.4
Jun 2020
Episode: 225
It’s Jenga
Karen and Georgia cover the life of Ida B. Wells and the Stonewall Uprising.28
May 2020
Episode: 224
What’s In Your Pants?
Karen and Georgia cover the Angel Makers of Nagyrév and killer priest Hans Schmidt.21
May 2020
Episode: 223
Live at the Paramount Theatre in Oakland (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover Zodiac Killer suspects and the murder of Stephanie Bryan.14
May 2020
Episode: 222
That’s How Water Works
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Madalyn Murray O'Hair and the survival story of Juliane Koepcke.7
May 2020
Episode: 221
Symbolic Violins
Karen and Georgia cover the rescue of Baby Jessica and the deaths of Sid Vicious and Nancy Spungen.30
Apr 2020
Episode: 220
Live at the Chevalier Theatre in Medford, MA (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Mary-Lou Arruda and The Great Boston Fire of 1872.23
Apr 2020
Episode: 219
Small Pillow To Scream In
Karen and Georgia cover PSA Flight 1771 and the Kent State massacre.16
Apr 2020
Episode: 218
Good Shabbos
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Yara Gambirasio, and the crimes of Herb Coddington.9
Apr 2020
Episode: 217
Live at the Cobb Energy Performing Arts Centre in Atlanta (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the curse of Lake Lanier and Anjette Donovan Lyles.2
Apr 2020
Episode: 216
Robe Convention
Karen and Georgia cover the deaths of Grace Kelly and Kendrick Johnson.26
Mar 2020
Episode: 215
Three Small Hot Dogs
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Natalie Wood and the Boxcar Killer.19
Mar 2020
Episode: 214
Live at the Davies Symphony Hall in San Francisco (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Cecelia Bowers and the Alcatraz Escape of 1962.12
Mar 2020
Episode: 213
Live at the Northrop Auditorium in Minneapolis (2019)
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Louis Arbogast and Harry Hayward.5
Mar 2020
Episode: 212
Hot Money
Karen and Georgia cover astronaut Sally Ride, the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster, and the Corpsewood Manor murders.27
Feb 2020
Episode: 211
It Was My Birthday, Forensic Files!
Karen and Georgia cover the hijacking of Pan Am Flight 73 and the Tulsa race massacre.20
Feb 2020
Episode: 210
Every Plan Is A Bad Plan
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Mary Phagan and revenge murder of Leo Frank, and the Wonderland murders.13
Feb 2020
Episode: 209
Big Sweater Energy
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Davina Buff Jones and Tiffany Taylor’s survivor story.6
Feb 2020
Episode: 208
208 - Live at the Orpheum Theater in Omaha (2019)
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of John Sheedy and Cari Farver.30
Jan 2020
Episode: 207
Not Enough Ednas
Karen and Georgia cover the Fairbanks Four and the Dixmoor Five cases and the Pillowcase Rapist.23
Jan 2020
Episode: 206
Spatula City
Karen and Georgia cover Laurie Dann, the Winnetka School shooter and Leopold and Loeb.16
Jan 2020
Episode: 205
Everyone Gets A Horse!
Karen and Georgia cover the Blackout Murders and Scott Scurlock, the Hollywood Bandit.9
Jan 2020
Episode: 204
Periodical Time Tables
Karen and Georgia cover The Butcher Baker Robert Hansen and the mysterious murder of Dorothy Jane Scott.2
Jan 2020
Episode: 203
Live at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta (2018)
Karen and Georgia cover the kidnapping of Barbara Mackle and the Barbie Bandits. With special guest Chuck Bryant.26
Dec 2019
Episode: 202
Live at the Sony Centre in Toronto (Night Two)
Karen and Georgia cover the Ant Hill Cult and the murder of Renee Sweeney.19
Dec 2019
Episode: 201
Live at Revolution Hall in Portland (2017)
Karen and Georgia cover William Scott Smith and the murders at Crater Lake.12
Dec 2019
Episode: 200
The Humility of Knowing: A 200th Episode Spectacular
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of Johnny Gosch and the Malahide massacre.5
Dec 2019
Episode: 199
Live at the Eventim Apollo in London
Karen and Georgia cover Dr. Thomas Neill Cream and the Enfield Poltergeist.28
Nov 2019
Episode: 198
Live at the Bord Gáis Energy Theatre in Dublin
Karen and Georgia cover Dorcas ‘Darkey’ Kelly and ‘Lying Eyes’ Sharon Collins.21
Nov 2019
Episode: 197
Grandma Surprise
Karen and Georgia cover the origin of ‘Stockholm Syndrome’ and Mack Ray Edwards.14
Nov 2019
Episode: 196
The Baddest Of Them All
Karen and Georgia cover the Gray Widow Murderers and the Burger Chef Murders.7
Nov 2019
Episode: 195
Live at My Favorite Weekend in Santa Barbara
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of the Salomon Family and the Thor Nis Christiansen at the Arlington Theatre. With special guest Carol Daly.31
Oct 2019
Episode: 194
The SpoOoky Halloween Hometown Special
Karen and Georgia celebrate Halloween by reading your spooky stories.24
Oct 2019
Episode: 193
The Lowest Limit
Karen and Georgia cover Gerald and Charlene Gallego, and ‘hitman’ Gary Krueger.17
Oct 2019
Episode: 192
Sticking Together & Helping Out
Karen and Georgia cover the disappearance of Emanuela Orlandi, and story of the Oversteegen Sisters and Hannie Schaft.10
Oct 2019
Episode: 191
Live at the Arvest Bank Theatre in Kansas City
Karen and Georgia cover the Meeks Family Murder and the Hotel President haunting.3
Oct 2019
Episode: 190
Lick The Clock
Karen and Georgia cover the Radium Girls and the murder of Lisa Cihaski.26
Sep 2019
Episode: 189
What Wonderful Luck!
Karen and Georgia cover the alleged real life story of The Orphan and the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire.19
Sep 2019
Episode: 188
The You & Me Of This Group
Karen and Georgia cover the Dyatlov Pass mystery and Linda Hazzard.18
Sep 2019
Episode: Bonus
Fox’s Prodigal Son Special!
In a special presentation for Fox’s new drama Prodigal Son, Karen and Georgia cover the cases of Sante Kimes and Dolly Oesterreich. Plus, an interview with star Bellamy Young!12
Sep 2019
Episode: 187
Live at the Toyota Music Factory in Irving (Texas)
Karen and Georgia cover the Texas Cheerleader Mom Murder Plot and the case of Vicky Lyons. With special guest Skip Hollandsworth.4
Sep 2019
Episode: 186
Sprankers!
Karen and Georgia cover the obsessive case of Carl Tanzler and stories of people buried alive.29
Aug 2019
Episode: 185
400 Peeled Potatoes
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Angie Dodge and the case of Dr. Malachi Love-Robinson.22
Aug 2019
Episode: 184
Weighted Blanket
Karen and Georgia cover The Doodler and the deaths of Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon.15
Aug 2019
Episode: 183
Here We Back Are
Karen and Georgia cover Jacob Wetterling and the Mothman legend & Silver Bridge collapse.8
Aug 2019
Episode: #1
MFM The Top 3: #1 - Episode 18 - Investigateighteen Discovery
Drumroll please...It’s #1 of your top three favorite episodes: Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Mary Vincent and Franklin Delano Floyd. Original airdate: 05/27/20161
Aug 2019
Episode: #2
MFM The Top 3: #2 - Episode 129 - Coincidence Island
It’s #2 of your top three favorite episodes: Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair. Original airdate: 07/12/201825
Jul 2019
Episode: #3
MFM The Top 3: #3 - Episode 105 - Proclensity
You voted for your favorite episodes and this week it's #3: Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Christa Worthington and the case of Typhoid Mary. Original airdate: 01/25/201818
Jul 2019
Episode: 182
Something Kevin-y (The Book Q&A)
You asked, they answered! Karen and Georgia respond to all your questions about their new book, Stay Sexy and Don’t Get Murdered.11
Jul 2019
Episode: 181
Live at the Riverside Theater in Milwaukee (2017)
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers David Spanbauer and Ed Gein.4
Jul 2019
Episode: 180
Live at the Tampa Theatre in Tampa
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Oscar Ray Bolin and Bobby Joe Long.27
Jun 2019
Episode: 179
Live at Clusterfest in San Francisco
Karen and Georgia cover the Mitchell Brothers murder and Ted Kaczynski. With special guest Patton Oswalt.20
Jun 2019
Episode: 178
Live at the Folketeatret in Oslo
Karen and Georgia cover the Isdal Woman and the Black Metal murders.13
Jun 2019
Episode: 177
Live at the Riverside Theater in Milwaukee
Karen and Georgia cover Laurie "Bambi" Bembenek and the murder of Barbara Kendhammer.6
Jun 2019
Episode: 176
The LA Book Tour Event at the Wilshire Ebell Theatre
This week, comedian Lizzy Cooperman hosts the last night of the Stay Sexy & Don't Get Murdered book tour.30
May 2019
Episode: 175
Live at the Civic Center Music Hall in Oklahoma City
Karen and Georgia cover the High Hat Club Killer and the Oklahoma City Butcher.23
May 2019
Episode: 174
Rough Winds & High Waters
Karen and Georgia cover the bodies of Mount Everest and then Karen did the Weepy-Voiced Killer.16
May 2019
Episode: 173
Live at W. L. Lyons Brown Theatre in Louisville
Karen and Georgia cover the Torture House of 1924 and the Murder of Marlene Oakes.9
May 2019
Episode: 172
I’m Fine, Look Away
Karen and Georgia cover the death of Joan Robinson Hill and the murder at Devil’s Teeth.2
May 2019
Episode: 171
Live at the Bellco Theatre in Denver
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Adolph Coors III and the Colorado Cannibal.25
Apr 2019
Episode: 170
Habeas Delicious
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Helle Crafts and the Hyatt Regency walkway collapse.18
Apr 2019
Episode: 169
This Old Sandwich
Karen and Georgia cover the Power Rangers Murder(s) and the murder of Denise Huber.11
Apr 2019
Episode: 168
Live at the Civic Center in Des Moines
Karen and Georgia cover Tracey Richter and the Villisca Axe Murders.4
Apr 2019
Episode: 167
Bomb Grade
Karen and Georgia cover the death of Karen Silkwood and serial killer Sam Little.28
Mar 2019
Episode: 166
Respecting the History of Coins
Karen and Georgia cover the Cincinnati Who Stampede Concert and Glennon Engleman.21
Mar 2019
Episode: 165
Live at the Old National Centre in Indianapolis
Karen and Georgia cover the Richmond Hill explosion and the murder of Marjorie Jackson.14
Mar 2019
Episode: 164
Live at the Sony Centre in Toronto
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Julie Stanton and the Massey Maid Murder.7
Mar 2019
Episode: 163
Nine Cocaines
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Bob Crane and the Dexter Copycat Killer.28
Feb 2019
Episode: 162
Prom Queen City
Karen and Georgia cover murderer Mark "Gator" Rogowski and the murder of Jane Bashara.21
Feb 2019
Episode: 161
Live at the Blaisdell Concert Hall in Honolulu
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Yvonne Mathison and the Maui Yoga Twin case.14
Feb 2019
Episode: 160
Cynthia & Barry
Karen and Georgia cover the story of Eddie Aikau and the Sleepwalking Murderer.7
Feb 2019
Episode: 159
Live at the Lyric in Baltimore
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Carolyn Wasilewski and the Baltimore Plot.31
Jan 2019
Episode: 158
Burn Day
Karen and Georgia cover the 3 Billboards murder of Kathy Page and the San Ysidro McDonald's Massacre.24
Jan 2019
Episode: 157
Live at the Civic Theatre in San Diego
Karen and Georgia cover the Torrey Pines Beach Murders and the Rose Petal Murder.17
Jan 2019
Episode: 156
Mr. Cool & Nice - The Conan O'Brien Episode
Karen and Georgia sit down with Conan O'Brien to discuss his obsession with true crime. Header Image Source: Photo by Jacek Dylag on Unsplash10
Jan 2019
Episode: 155
You Don't Know What You Don't Know
Karen and Georgia cover the murders of Su Taraskiewicz and Abraham Shakespeare.3
Jan 2019
Episode: 154
DNA Dad
Karen and Georgia cover the mysterious death of Thelma Todd and the Footpath Murders.20
Dec 2018
Episode: 152
Live at the O2 Academy in Glasgow
Karen and Georgia cover the Burke & Hare murders and the Bible John murders.13
Dec 2018
Episode: 151
Live at the Queen Elizabeth Theatre in Vancouver
Karen and Georgia cover the Abbotsford Killer and the Salish Sea human foot mystery.6
Dec 2018
Episode: 150
How Dare You Kelli
Karen and Georgia cover the hanging of Alice Riley and the murder of Reyna Marroquin.29
Nov 2018
Episode: 149
Lifestyle & Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Missoula Mauler and the Forest Park Killer.22
Nov 2018
Episode: 148
Live at the Community Center Theater in Sacramento
Karen and Georgia cover attempted assassin Squeaky Fromme and the Lodi Haystack Murder. Plus surprise guest Paul Holes.15
Nov 2018
Episode: 147
Live in Austin
Karen and Georgia cover Robert Elmer Kleason and the murder of Steven Robards.8
Nov 2018
Episode: 146
Dawna's Skinny Lighter
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Randy Mock and the Seattle Cyanide Poisonings.1
Nov 2018
Episode: 145
Live at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover the satanic panic of McMartin Pre-School and the Mannequin at the Carnival.25
Oct 2018
Episode: 144
Live at the Chevalier Theatre in Medford, MA
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of George Parkman and the Great Molasses Flood of 1919.18
Oct 2018
Episode: 143
Desabotage
Karen and Georgia cover the truth behind poisoned Halloween candy and the murder of Carol Stuart.11
Oct 2018
Episode: 142
Live at the Durham Performing Arts Center
Karen and Georgia cover the Lawson Family murders and the Bitter Blood murders.4
Oct 2018
Episode: 141
Big Thirsty Robe
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Heidi and Christine and the murder of Linda Bailey Brown.20
Sep 2018
Episode: 139
A Hundred Feelings
Karen and Georgia cover the Kunz Family Murders and the murder of Joan Dawley.13
Sep 2018
Episode: 138
Live at the Red Rocks Ballroom in Las Vegas
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Gerard Soules and the death of Ted Binion.6
Sep 2018
Episode: 137
Gloogle
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of BBC reporter Jill Dando and the Andrews’ Family ‘Hauntings.’30
Aug 2018
Episode: 136
The Uninhibited
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Stanford White and the case of the Boys on the Tracks.23
Aug 2018
Episode: 135
The Multiverse Trajectory
Karen and Georgia cover the Party Monster murder of Angel Melendez and the story of Clarence and Melinda Elkins.16
Aug 2018
Episode: 134
Live at the Connor Palace in Cleveland
Karen and Georgia cover Ed Edwards and the Kirtland cult killings.9
Aug 2018
Episode: 133
Made of Crystals
Karen and Georgia cover the Gainesville Ripper and the Lady of the Dunes.2
Aug 2018
Episode: 132
Awful Peanut
Karen and Georgia cover the cult of Synanon and the death of Azaria Chamberlain.27
Jul 2018
Episode: 131
Live at the Chinateatern in Stockholm
Karen and Georgia cover Nikita Bergenström and Sture Bergwall aka Thomas Quick.19
Jul 2018
Episode: 130
Mike is Right
Karen and Georgia cover the Fall of the Romanovs and Fred and Rosemary West.12
Jul 2018
Episode: 129
Coincidence Island
Karen and Georgia cover the Honolulu Strangler and the Galapagos Affair.5
Jul 2018
Episode: 128
Live at Albert Hall in Manchester
Karen and Georgia cover serial killers Mary Ann Britland and Trevor Hardy.28
Jun 2018
Episode: 127
Our Beautiful Rat King
Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Angela Samota and Finland’s Lake Bodom murders.21
Jun 2018
Episode: 126
Nice Office
Karen and Georgia cover the case of Lawrence DeLisle and the murder of Kim Wall.14
Jun 2018
Episode: 125
Bedside Astrologer!
Karen and Georgia cover the survival story of Scott Johnston and Sean Farmer and the Glamour Girl Slayer.7
Jun 2018
Episode: 124
Errant Duct Tape
Karen and Georgia cover the unsolved crimes of Mr. Cruel and the murder of Girly Chew Hossencofft.31
May 2018
Episode: 123
Live at Vicar Street in Dublin
Karen and Georgia cover Colin Whelan and the Stoneybatter Strangler.10
May 2018
Episode: 120
Live at the Orpheum in Los Angeles
Karen and Georgia cover LA crime journalist Agness Underwood and the Los Feliz Murder Mansion.3
May 2018
Episode: 119
Fingers Everywhere
Karen and Georgia cover the Lipstick Killer and the Lindbergh Baby kidnapping.26
Apr 2018
Episode: 118
Golden State Serial Killer Caught
Karen and Georgia cover the arrest of the Golden State Killer. Plus investigative journalist Billy Jensen calls in.19
Apr 2018
Episode: 117
Reality's Canceled
Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Teka Adams and the West Mesa Bone Collector.12
Apr 2018
Episode: 116
Robot Grandma
Karen and Georgia cover killers Jesse Pomeroy and Issei Sagawa.14
Jan 2016
Episode: 1
My Firstest Murder
In the very first episode, Karen and Georgia discuss car accidents, JonBenét Ramsey, and the Sacramento's East Area Rapist. Plus a local story from Feral Audio founder, Dustin Martian.
Listen
Exactly Right Media
