Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.
26
May 2022
Episode: 328
The Year is 2243
On today’s episode, Karen covers the death of socialite Sunny von Bülow and Georgia tells more stories of bodies found in chimneys.
Note: this episode was recorded before the horrific tragedy in Uvalde, Texas.
In Mini Minisode 43, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia narrates a trick-or-treat adventure and Karen spills the office tea.
In Mini Minisode 42, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week includes advice for living alone and James Brown.
In Mini Minisode 41, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen creeps us out with a sex education experience and Georgia tells a drunk baby tale.
In Mini Minisode 40, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan cult. Georgia details a first grader’s most embarrassing moment and Karen gives a serotonin boost with the adventure of Chirp.
On today's episode, Georgia and Karen cover the tragic disappearance of Kelsey Collins and the miraculous survival of Captain Tim Lancaster on British Airways Flight 5390.
In Mini Minisode 39, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells a scammer tale and Georgia shares a touching story from a survivor.
In Mini Minisode 38, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia covers a forbidden love story and Karen details a Murderino’s famous family.
In Mini Minisode 37, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen details a sock drawer snoop and Georgia takes us through a rollercoaster of emotions over a dwarf hamster.
In Mini Minisode 36, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia describes a princess adventure and Karen warms the heart with a ghost story.
In Mini Minisode 35, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week includes a party with a murder suspect and a grandma named Arlene.
In Mini Minisode 34, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a tattle's tale and Karen narrates a joy ride.
In Mini Minisode 33, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen explains what happens when you marry a former Eagle Scout and Georgia details the time a listener was followed.
In Mini Minisode 32, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares a listener’s Italian fiasco and Karen details what happens when a kid is put in charge.
In Mini Minisode 31, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a story of mistaken identity and Karen shares how a listener’s mom stayed sexy and didn’t get murdered.
In Mini Minisode 30, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia’s story dives into a cult and Karen’s boasts about a badass with killer instinct.
In Mini Minisode 29, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen retells a ouija board horror and Georgia tells a tale about a shitty kid.
In Mini Minisode 28, Karen and Georgia tug at the heartstrings with two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a story about a pumpkin and Karen shares how a listener almost killed.
In Mini Minisode 27, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia reads a tale about an all-star mall hairstylist who saved a living room wedding and Karen shares a personal I SURVIVED story from a listener.
In Mini Minisode 26, Georgia and Karen read two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares a story about a fur coat-wearing talent scout and Karen retells a listener tale about a beloved protector named Levi.
In Mini Minisode 25, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen shares a story about an aunt's murderous high school sweetheart and Georgia reads a hometown from a listener who's dad got his ass stuck in a wall.
In Mini Minisode 24, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen's epic story is about a child's past life in Tulsa and Georgia tells a listener tale about a sister's attempted murder via peanut allergy.
In Mini Minisode 23, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia shares the origin story of a Murderino whose teacher overshared about jury duty. Karen retells a listener's story about poor parental decisions and some heroic Australians.
On today's episode, Karen covers the Miracle in the Andes: the Uruguayan Flight 571 crash, and Georgia tells the story of Celia Cooney, the Bobbed Haired Bandit.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Megan Mullally.
In Mini Minisode 22, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen's story is a great one about how a 14-year-old got a group of medical professionals drunk at a holiday party. Georgia shares the tale of a listener who caught her little brother inhaling whipped cream.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Nick Offerman.
In Mini Minisode 21, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Karen tells a story of a mother's life-saving intuition and Georgia shares a listener's best-case scenario while wearing a towel story.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Phoebe Bridgers.
In Mini Minisode 20, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. Georgia tells a listener story of someone getting a baby drunk and Karen's story of Roman cokes ruining Christmas.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Nicole Byer.
In Mini Minisode 19, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, Georgia's story is a tale of neighborly murder and Karen offers a great story about a kid denying the identity of her dad at daycare.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Margaret Cho.
In Mini Minisode 18, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, both stories revolve around the scattering of cremains - one accidentally and one secretly.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Wanda Sykes.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Patton Oswalt.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is crime fighter turned podcaster, Paul Holes.
In Mini Minisode 17, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a lost car and a burly ally in a late-night parking garage and a haunted bath robe on fire.
On today's episode, Karen covers Scottish serial killer Dennis Nilsen and Georgia tells the story of Detective Jack Whicher and the Road Hill House murder.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest comedian Michelle Buteau.
In Mini Minisode 16, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a tricky little spirit in a house and an extremely terrible Halloween prank.
In Mini Minisode 15, Georgia and Karen share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a very bad bank manager and a New Hampshire-based relative of H. H. Holmes the 19th century American serial killer.
For a special treat, Karen and Georgia sit down with celebrity guests to hear their stories, from hometown murders to personal accounts of mayhem to legendary family lore. Today's guest is Josh Mankiewicz of NBC's Dateline.
In Mini Minisode 14, Karen and Georgia share two bonus hometown stories just for the Fan Cult. This week, they tell the story of a real-life The Orphan and the twisted tale of a Denver cemetery relocation.
This week, Georgia and Karen cover the unsolved cases of three Indigenous women, Kiana Klomp, Amber Tuccaro, and Ella Mae Begay, and the disappearance of Lawrence Joseph Bader.
In Mini Minisode 13 (they're back!), Georgia and Karen do two extra hometown stories. In this episode, the gals share the insane story of purposeful poisonings and an aunt's beloved octopus ring.
In Mini Minisode 12 (they're back!), Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a hostage negotiator father and an anti-racist family who doles out KKK clap backs!
In Mini Minisode 11 (they're back!), Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a gallows-collecting Texan dad and latch key kid with a vigilant Swedish father.
This week, Karen and Georgia cover the cold case murders of Barbara Oberholtzer and Annette Schnee and the mysterious disappearance of the Candy Lady, Helen Brach.
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Nick Terry, creator of MFM Animated (youtube.com/exactlyrightmedia). Nick covers Stories of People Buried Alive (Episode 186) and the story of The Mothman Legend & Silver Bridge Collapse (Episode 183).
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Erin & Erin, hosts of This Podcast Will Kill You on Exactly Right. The Erins cover the stories of The Incredible Survival of Jennifer Morey (Episode 33) and The Tragic Death of Mitrice Richardson (Episode 65).
his summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Kate Winkler Dawson, host of Tenfold More Wicked and Wicked Words on Exactly Right. Kate covers the stories of The Murder of Irene Garza (Episode 99) and Fred and Rosemary West (Episode 130).
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Bridger Winegar, host of I Said No Gifts! on Exactly Right. Bridger covers The Murders of Master Forger Mark Hofmann (Episode 76) and The Sleepwalking Murderer (Episode 160).
MFM Guest Host Picks #8: Kyle Russell (kikiwithkiki)
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by content creator Kyle Russell (kikiwithkiki), one of social media’s favorite Karen and Georgia lip syncers. Kyle shares the stories of the Amityville Horror Murders (Episode 90) and the Lindbergh Baby Kidnapping (Episode 119).
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Kara Klenk, co-host of That's Messed Up: An SVU Podcast on Exactly Right. Kara covers the stories of Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka (Episode 91), Joseph Edward Duncan III (Episode 63), and a special hometown (Episode 16).
This summer, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Danielle Henderson, co-host of I Saw What You Did on Exactly Right. Danielle shares the stories of Who Put Bella in the Wych Elm? (Episode 10) and Lord Lucan (Episode 45).
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Scotty Landes, co-host of Bananas on Exactly Right. Scotty covers the stories of the Oakland County Child Killer (Episode 3) and the Martha Moxley Murder Case (Episode 5).
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Brandie Posey, co-host of Lady to Lady on Exactly Right. Brandie shares the stories of the Fort Worth Three Kidnapping and John Wayne Gacy (Live from the Chicago Podcast Festival - Episode 44).
This week’s MFM’s Guest Host Pick features Billy Jensen from JENSEN & HOLES: THE MURDER SQUAD. Billy introduces us to two of his favorite stories from past episodes of My Favorite Murder. From Episode 163 on March 7, 2019, Georgia covers Mark Twitchell, the Dexter Copycat Killer. And Karen’s story of the murder of Bonnie Lee Bakley is from Episode 112 from March 15, 2018.
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Elizabeth Taylor — host of The True Beauty Brooklyn Podcast on Exactly Right — covering the stories of the Tulsa Race Massacre (Episode 211) and the Murder of Angie Dodge (Episode 185).
Throughout the months of June and July, Exactly Right family members will be guest hosting My Favorite Murder! Each week a guest host will pick their favorite stories from Karen and Georgia.
Today's episode is hosted by Steven Ray Morris—MFM audio engineer and host of The Purrrcast—covering the stories of Selena (Episode 32) and The Lady of the Dunes (Episode 133).
In Mini Minisode 10, Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a terrible doctor who was not to be trusted and a mysterious vibration.
In Mini Minisode 9, Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, they share the stories of a nearly murderous roller coaster and a dare involving a car's cigarette lighter.
Welcome to Mini Minisode 8, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear about a toddler with a fascination with electricity and a couple of murderous neighbors.
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's stories include an unlocked door after a rough night and a haunted chemistry lab.
Welcome to Mini Minisode 6, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear about a mishap at a Christian college and a surprise panic button.
Welcome to Mini Minisode 5, in which Karen and Georgia do two extra hometown stories, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. In this episode, we hear the story about delayed justice in small-town New Jersey and an unwelcome visitor during a well-deserved nap.
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's story include a maxed out backpack and a possessed vibrator.
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week's stories include dump truck drama and a student driver rundown.
In a new series, exclusively for members of the Fan Cult, Karen and Georgia are doing two extra hometown stories per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. This week’s stories include a 4-year old savior and a fatherly encounter with an escaped inmate.
For your ears only, Karen and Georgia are doing one extra hometown story per week, pulled exclusively from the Fan Cult forum. The premiere episode of the Mini Minisode includes a scary parking structure story from the 70s and the continuation of the ball pit saga.
In a special presentation for Fox’s new drama Prodigal Son, Karen and Georgia cover the cases of Sante Kimes and Dolly Oesterreich. Plus, an interview with star Bellamy Young!
MFM The Top 3: #1 - Episode 18 - Investigateighteen Discovery
Drumroll please...It’s #1 of your top three favorite episodes: Karen and Georgia cover the survival of Mary Vincent and Franklin Delano Floyd. Original airdate: 05/27/2016
You voted for your favorite episodes and this week it's #3: Karen and Georgia cover the murder of Christa Worthington and the case of Typhoid Mary.
Original airdate: 01/25/2018
In the very first episode, Karen and Georgia discuss car accidents, JonBenét Ramsey, and the Sacramento's East Area Rapist. Plus a local story from Feral Audio founder, Dustin Martian.
This page uses cookies and other similar technologies to improve your experience on our services. When browsing or using our services, the user accepts the use of "cookies". Find out more in our Privacy Policy.